Platerian
ENES

Italian in Hialeah

74 businessesRanked by quality scoreRanked on Google reviews · Yelp shown for comparisonUpdated July 19, 2026

74 Italian food businesses in Hialeah, ranked by the same fused quality score (Google rating and review volume) used across the rest of the site, from public Google review data.

Found 74 results

#BusinessGoogle ratingYelp ratingCombined ratingGoogle vs. YelpPrice
1Pa’Comer Cuban PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.72,221 reviews★ 4.289 reviews★ 4.72,310 reviews total▲ 0.5$
2Star Chiguas Pizza CubanaHialeah · Italian★ 4.61,167 reviews★ 3.715 reviews★ 4.61,182 reviews total-$
3Hialeah Hakuna Matata Pizza CubanaHialeah · Italian★ 4.61,042 reviews★ 4.648 reviews★ 4.61,090 reviews total·$
4El Palenque Pizzería CubanaHialeah · Italian★ 4.51,875 reviews---$
5Queens NY PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.7410 reviews★ 4.447 reviews★ 4.7457 reviews total▲ 0.3$
6Pizzería Twin Tower big & tastyHialeah · Italian★ 4.6461 reviews★ 3.411 reviews★ 4.6472 reviews total-$$
7Farandula Pizzeria HialeahHialeah · Italian★ 4.41,251 reviews★ 3.04 reviews★ 4.41,255 reviews total-$
8Pizza Station 826Hialeah · Italian★ 4.6436 reviews★ 3.7122 reviews★ 4.4558 reviews total▲ 0.9$
9Tony's PlaceHialeah · Italian★ 4.6377 reviews★ 4.0101 reviews★ 4.5478 reviews total▲ 0.6$
10La Guajira PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 4.41,149 reviews★ 3.130 reviews★ 4.41,179 reviews total▲ 1.3$
11Pizza CubanaHialeah · Italian★ 4.5600 reviews★ 3.38 reviews★ 4.5608 reviews total-$
12Dipiazza PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 4.51,089 reviews★ 4.1295 reviews★ 4.41,384 reviews total▲ 0.4$
13Blaze PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.6409 reviews★ 4.028 reviews★ 4.6437 reviews total▲ 0.6$
14Salvatore Pizza & PastaHialeah · Italian★ 4.5586 reviews★ 4.3253 reviews★ 4.4839 reviews total▲ 0.2$
15RICO PAN PIZZERIA & GRILLHialeah · Italian★ 4.6398 reviews★ 4.491 reviews★ 4.6489 reviews total▲ 0.2$
16Dimelo Pizzeria (Inside BP Gas Station)Hialeah · Italian★ 4.9192 reviews★ 4.04 reviews★ 4.9196 reviews total-$
17Paraiso TropicalHialeah · Italian★ 4.8226 reviews---$
18Zaza PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.8220 reviews---$
19Qbiche Restaurant | Pizza CubanaHialeah · Italian★ 4.4892 reviews★ 2.77 reviews★ 4.4899 reviews total-$
20Lazardi's Italian CuisineHialeah · Italian★ 5.025 reviews---$
21ARIES PIZZAHialeah · Italian★ 4.5164 reviews---$
22El Palenque Pizzería CubanaHialeah · Italian★ 4.33,467 reviews★ 2.939 reviews★ 4.33,506 reviews total▲ 1.4$
23Mia Rosa PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 4.6326 reviews★ 3.97 reviews★ 4.6333 reviews total-$
24Pasta Lovers MiamiHialeah · Italian★ 5.020 reviews---$
25La Cubanita PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 4.4697 reviews★ 2.820 reviews★ 4.4717 reviews total-$
26La Bambina PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.6232 reviews★ 4.37 reviews★ 4.6239 reviews total--
27Pizza Cubana Trebol Pizzeria cafeteria y restaurant latín foodHialeah · Italian★ 4.5313 reviews★ 4.48 reviews★ 4.5321 reviews total-$
28Ready Dough PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 4.985 reviews★ 2.816 reviews★ 4.6101 reviews total-$
29Pizzeria MonacoHialeah · Italian★ 4.887 reviews---$
30Little Caesars PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.21,208 reviews★ 2.313 reviews★ 4.21,221 reviews total-$
31Manhattan Pizza PlaceHialeah · Italian★ 4.2580 reviews★ 3.6153 reviews★ 4.1733 reviews total▲ 0.6$
32Chris-Jule PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 5.031 reviews---$
33PizzamaninaHialeah · Italian★ 4.490 reviews----
34Riviera PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 4.554 reviews---$
35Naty's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.2219 reviews---$
36Toscana PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 4.447 reviews★ 1.03 reviews★ 4.250 reviews total--
37Marco's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.622 reviews---$
38Asere Batidos 4Hialeah · Italian★ 4.713 reviews---$
39Al's New York PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.271 reviews★ 4.532 reviews★ 4.3103 reviews total▼ 0.3$
40Pizza a mi i ManeraHialeah · Italian★ 5.05 reviews----
41PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 5.02 reviews----
42PizzeríaHialeah · Italian★ 3.73 reviews----
43Pizza Hut ExpressHialeah · Italian★ 3.910 reviews---$
44Asere Batidos 2Hialeah · Italian★ 4.1395 reviews---$
45bambinosauthenticitaliancuisine comHialeah · Italian★ 3.52 reviews★ 4.01 reviews★ 3.73 reviews total--
46Jerry & Joe's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.1454 reviews★ 3.229 reviews★ 4.0483 reviews total▲ 0.9$
47Fast'n Hot PizzeriaHialeah · Italian★ 1.02 reviews----
48Little Caesars PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.1547 reviews---$
49Rey's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.11,152 reviews★ 2.233 reviews★ 4.01,185 reviews total▲ 1.9$
50Little Caesars PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.11,648 reviews---$
51Cicis PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.12,104 reviews---$
52SbarroHialeah · Italian★ 3.963 reviews---$
53Little Caesars PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.0767 reviews★ 1.916 reviews★ 4.0783 reviews total-$
54Rey's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.01,110 reviews★ 2.151 reviews★ 3.91,161 reviews total▲ 1.9$
55Montes de Oca Original Pizza CubanaHialeah · Italian★ 3.9377 reviews---$$
56Rey's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 4.01,254 reviews★ 2.320 reviews★ 4.01,274 reviews total-$
57Pizza HutHialeah · Italian★ 3.9441 reviews★ 1.313 reviews★ 3.8454 reviews total-$
58Papa Johns PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.8349 reviews★ 2.88 reviews★ 3.8357 reviews total-$
59Pizza HutHialeah · Italian★ 3.8481 reviews★ 1.914 reviews★ 3.7495 reviews total-$
60Little Caesars PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.8543 reviews★ 1.718 reviews★ 3.7561 reviews total-$
61Papa Johns PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.5235 reviews★ 2.019 reviews★ 3.4254 reviews total-$
62Rey’s PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.91,972 reviews★ 2.213 reviews★ 3.91,985 reviews total-$
63Pizza HutHialeah · Italian★ 3.7580 reviews★ 1.921 reviews★ 3.6601 reviews total-$
64Olive Garden Italian RestaurantHialeah · Italian★ 4.35,764 reviews★ 2.9191 reviews★ 4.35,955 reviews total▲ 1.4$
65Little Caesars PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.5393 reviews★ 2.222 reviews★ 3.4415 reviews total-$
66Domino's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 2.9176 reviews---$
67Pizza HutHialeah · Italian★ 3.3316 reviews★ 1.723 reviews★ 3.2339 reviews total-$
68Pizza HutHialeah · Italian★ 3.5503 reviews★ 1.740 reviews★ 3.4543 reviews total▲ 1.8$
69Pizza HutHialeah · Italian★ 3.3433 reviews★ 1.537 reviews★ 3.2470 reviews total▲ 1.8$
70Domino's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.1626 reviews★ 1.335 reviews★ 3.0661 reviews total▲ 1.8$
71Domino's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.2972 reviews★ 1.462 reviews★ 3.11,034 reviews total▲ 1.8$
72Domino's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 3.1822 reviews★ 1.678 reviews★ 3.0900 reviews total▲ 1.5$
73Domino's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 2.9709 reviews★ 1.447 reviews★ 2.8756 reviews total▲ 1.5$
74Domino's PizzaHialeah · Italian★ 2.9726 reviews★ 1.839 reviews★ 2.8765 reviews total▲ 1.1$

See all categories in Hialeah · View Hialeah on the map

Other cuisines in Hialeah

American · Chinese · Mexican · Seafood · Vegan

This ranking compares businesses across every type (restaurant, cafe, bakery, and more) using the same fused quality score used elsewhere on the site, not the type-specific leaderboards above. Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.