Platerian
ENES

American in Hialeah

18 businessesRanked by quality scoreRanked on Google reviews · Yelp shown for comparisonUpdated July 19, 2026View on map

Right now, the top-rated American in Hialeah is PINCHO (4.5 stars).

The biggest Google-vs-Yelp gap among American spots in Hialeah is at Los Verdes - Miami Lakes: Google rates it 4.3 stars, Yelp 2.8.

Flanigan's Seafood Bar and Grill has the most Google reviews among American spots in Hialeah (4,770).

18 American food businesses in Hialeah, ranked by the same fused quality score (Google rating and review volume) used across the rest of the site, from public Google review data.

Found 17 results

#BusinessGoogle ratingYelp ratingCombined ratingGoogle vs. YelpPrice
1PINCHOHialeah · American★ 4.52,080 reviews★ 4.3456 reviews★ 4.42,536 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 4.3▲ 0.2$
2FuddruckersHialeah · American★ 4.42,646 reviews★ 3.5124 reviews★ 4.22,770 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 3.5▲ 0.9$
3Los Verdes - Miami LakesHialeah · American★ 4.32,495 reviews★ 2.8297 reviews★ 3.92,792 reviews totalGoogle 4.3 / Yelp 2.8▲ 1.5$
4Boss Tapas, Burger & BrewHialeah · American★ 4.4846 reviews★ 4.0572 reviews★ 4.21,418 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 4.0▲ 0.4$
5Yas! Burger BP GAS STATIONHialeah · American★ 4.6458 reviews---$
6Habit Burger & GrillHialeah · American★ 4.2266 reviews★ 3.727 reviews★ 4.1293 reviews totalGoogle 4.2 / Yelp 3.7▲ 0.5$
7El Polinesio Restaurante and Bar Hidden gemHialeah · American★ 4.641 reviews---$
8The Original Hot Dog Factory Hidden gemHialeah · American★ 4.548 reviews----
9Big tatos express grill 2 HialeahHialeah · American★ 4.421 reviews---$
10Cabana Craft EateryHialeah · American★ 5.02 reviews★ 4.37 reviews---
11Golf View Sports Bar & GrillHialeah · American★ 4.73 reviews★ 4.02 reviews--$$
12Five GuysHialeah · American★ 3.9115 reviews★ 3.98 reviews--$
13Ven con TitiHialeah · American★ 5.01 reviews----
14Kurva's Bar & GrillHialeah · American★ 4.453 reviews----
15Flanigan's Seafood Bar and GrillHialeah · American★ 4.44,770 reviews★ 3.6573 reviews★ 4.25,343 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 3.6▲ 0.8$
16The Original Ranch House RestaurantHialeah · American★ 4.3584 reviews★ 3.3129 reviews★ 4.0713 reviews totalGoogle 4.3 / Yelp 3.3▲ 1.0$
17Boston MarketHialeah · American★ 3.7385 reviews★ 2.343 reviews★ 3.4428 reviews totalGoogle 3.7 / Yelp 2.3▲ 1.4$

See all categories in Hialeah · View Hialeah on the map

Other cuisines in Hialeah

Chinese · Italian · Mexican · Seafood · Vegan

This ranking compares businesses across every type (restaurant, cafe, bakery, and more) using the same fused quality score used elsewhere on the site, not the type-specific leaderboards above. Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.