5 Pizzeria listings in Pinecrest

5 businessesSmall sampleRanked on Google reviews · Yelp shown for comparisonUpdated July 19, 2026View on map

Small sample (5 businesses), shown without a weighted ranking.

Business	Google rating	Yelp rating	Combined rating	Google vs. Yelp	Price
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - PinecrestPinecrest · Pizzeria	★ 4.93,372 reviews	★ 4.299 reviews	★ 4.83,471 reviews totalGoogle 4.9 / Yelp 4.2	▲ 0.7	$
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & WingsPinecrest · Pizzeria	★ 4.41,172 reviews	★ 3.7355 reviews	★ 4.21,527 reviews totalGoogle 4.4 / Yelp 3.7	▲ 0.7	$$
Manhattan Chicago PizzaPinecrest · Pizzeria	★ 3.6287 reviews	★ 3.1223 reviews	★ 3.4510 reviews totalGoogle 3.6 / Yelp 3.1	▲ 0.5	$
New York Roma Pizza Drive ThruPinecrest · Pizzeria	★ 4.5261 reviews	★ 3.685 reviews	★ 4.2346 reviews totalGoogle 4.5 / Yelp 3.6	▲ 0.9	$
Original Big TomatoPinecrest · Pizzeria	★ 4.3215 reviews	★ 3.8137 reviews	★ 4.1352 reviews totalGoogle 4.3 / Yelp 3.8	▲ 0.5	$

Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.