Top pizzeria in Miami Beach right now: Il Pizzaiolo 🍋🩵 - Neapolitan Pizzeria Miami Beach
Right now, the top-rated Pizzeria in Miami Beach is Il Pizzaiolo 🍋🩵 - Neapolitan Pizzeria Miami Beach (4.9 stars).
Across Miami-Dade, Pizzeria read 0.97 stars lower on Yelp than Google.
See this week's best pizzerias list for Miami Beach.
Filter
| # | Business | Google rating | Yelp rating | Combined rating | vs avg | Google vs. Yelp | Price | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Il Pizzaiolo 🍋🩵 - Neapolitan Pizzeria Miami Beach | +0.7 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.6 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.4 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#1 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 5,340 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 2 | Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - South Beach | +0.6 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.5 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.3 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#2 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 3,670 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 3 | La Leggenda Pizzeria | +0.4 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.3 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.2 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#3 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 3,655 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 4 | P.Pole Pizza Miami Beach | - | - | +0.7 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.6 vs all ★4.3 | - | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#4 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 1,228 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |
| 5 | Mega Pizza | +0.2 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.1 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 1.3 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#5 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 2,091 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 6 | Nick's Pizza South Beach | +0.3 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.2 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.8 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#6 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 1,523 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 7 | Banchero Miami | +0.3 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.2 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.5 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#7 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 2,306 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 8 | Grafa Pizza | +0.2 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.1 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.6 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#8 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 2,304 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 9 | Pizza De Miami 2 | - | +0.5 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.4 vs all ★4.3 | - | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#9 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 1,223 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | ||
| 10 | Spris Artisan Pizza - Lincoln Road | +0.2 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2+0.1 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.5 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#10 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 1,937 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 11 | Pizza Rustica South Beach | 0.0 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2-0.1 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.7 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#11 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 3,497 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 12 | Pizza Bar Miami Beach | -0.1 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2-0.2 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.7 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#12 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 3,035 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 13 | Lucali | -0.1 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2-0.2 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 0.3 | $$ | high confidenceWhy this result?#13 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 1,765 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. | |||
| 14 | Venezia Grill, Pizzeria & Bar | -0.7 vs pizzeria avg ★4.2-0.8 vs all ★4.3 | ▲ 1.1 | $ | high confidenceWhy this result?#14 of 56 · Pizzeria in Miami Beach · high confidence · Google reviews only · updated July 19, 2026 1,634 Google reviews in total. A single data snapshot; no trend history yet. |
Averages (Google-based): pizzeria cohort ★4.2 · all Miami-Dade venues ★4.3 (17,504 total).
Every ranking here uses public Google review data only. See the methodology.