The 10 best ice cream shops in Miami Beach: CIAO AMORE Italian Gelato, Caffè & Bakery
★4.9 combined1,302 reviews#1 of 10Updated July 19, 2026
First edition. No change history yet.
| # | Business | Combined rating | vs avg |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CIAO AMORE Italian Gelato, Caffè & Bakery | +0.6 vs ice-cream+0.6 vs all | |
| 2 | Icy-N-Spicy | +0.5 vs ice-cream+0.5 vs all | |
| 3 | US Love Ice Cream | +0.6 vs ice-cream+0.6 vs all | |
| 4 | Van Leeuwen Ice Cream | +0.6 vs ice-cream+0.6 vs all | |
| 5 | Legendairy Milkshake Bar | +0.5 vs ice-cream+0.5 vs all | |
| 6 | Tatore Gelato | +0.6 vs ice-cream+0.6 vs all | |
| 7 | Aubi & Ramsa | +0.6 vs ice-cream+0.6 vs all | |
| 8 | Mella Ice Cream and Yogurt | +0.6 vs ice-cream+0.6 vs all | |
| 9 | Mammamia Gelato Italiano | +0.4 vs ice-cream+0.4 vs all | |
| 10 | I Scream Gelato - Miami, FL | +0.4 vs ice-cream+0.4 vs all |
Edition history
Combined rating: pooled evidence across every available platform, weighted by the square root of each platform's review count, then adjusted toward this cohort's typical rating when the evidence is thin. See the methodology.