The 8 best pizzerias in Aventura

8 businessesUpdated July 18, 2026

First edition. No change history yet.

#	Business	Combined rating	Platforms	Standing
1	Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - AventuraAventura · Pizzeria	★ 4.86,932 reviews total	Google 4.96,752 reviewsYelp 4.3180 reviews	93.8th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura
2	Pizza bakeryAventura · Pizzeria	★ 4.5105 reviews total	Google 4.8105 reviews	81.3th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura
3	Itálica Pizza BarAventura · Pizzeria	★ 4.41,388 reviews total	Google 4.61,291 reviewsYelp 3.797 reviews	68.8th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura
4	Mama Pizza & Coffee ShoopAventura · Pizzeria	★ 4.4568 reviews total	Google 4.5541 reviewsYelp 3.927 reviews	56.3th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura
5	Mario The BakerAventura · Pizzeria	★ 4.21,786 reviews total	Google 4.51,628 reviewsYelp 3.1158 reviews	43.8th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura
6	Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & WingsAventura · Pizzeria	★ 4.12,099 reviews total	Google 4.31,669 reviewsYelp 3.8430 reviews	31.3th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura
7	Domino's PizzaAventura · Pizzeria	★ 4.0391 reviews total	Google 3.8391 reviews	18.8th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura
8	Villa PizzaAventura · Pizzeria	★ 3.8384 reviews total	Google 3.9353 reviewsYelp 2.531 reviews	6.3th percentile among pizzerias in Aventura

Edition history

July 18, 2026 (current)

Combined rating: pooled evidence across every available platform, weighted by the square root of each platform's review count, then adjusted toward this cohort's typical rating when the evidence is thin. See the methodology.